First, will be the coherence and clarity of your argument. Apply the knowledge you gain on the units of critical thinking of logical fallacies to your work. Is it self-contradictory? Does your work assume what it needs to prove? Are you using double standards or biases in favor of your conclusion? Are you careful to avoid presenting the view you reject as a strawman? Second, how clearly you following the organization structure provided below.
Pointers for writing
Don’t go “all in” on debatable points or point that you will no devote time to support
Avoiding lengthy quotes that pad your word count. If you cite more than 3 lines of text, make them single space and indent the whole quote.
Avoid overly repeating what you’ve already said (padding the word count)
Do identify what ethical philosophy each of the authors is taking (the author’s point of view)
Do identify what position each author takes on the ethical issue
Do identify who the you agrees with and why. The student should respond to the objections raised by the author that they disagree with.