Can you identify the thesis statement?
Does it address the main points that the writer will be making in the essay?
Has the writer addressed all aspects of critical reading and analysis as covered in this course?
Add any notes on content here:
Organization YES NO
Is the introduction effective in engaging the reader while providing an overview of the main ideas of the paper?
Can you identify the topic sentences for each body paragraph?
Does the paper effectively use transitions?
Is the conclusion effective?
Does the conclusion summarize the main points and bring the discussion to a logical and satisfying ending?
Add any notes on organization here:
Format YES NO
Does the essay use appropriate APA formatting, including double-spacing, Times New
Roman, 12-point font, 1″ margins, and appropriate paragraph indentations?
Can you identify any areas where outside sources appear to be used without including in-text citations?
If so, provide specific examples here:
When in-text citations are used, do they follow APA formatting?
Can you identify any issues with the reference page?
Grammar and Mechanics YES NO
Does the writer use proper grammar, punctuation, and spelling?
Is the writing clear and comprehensible throughout the draft?
If not, provide specific examples of areas that need improvement here:
When in-text citations are used, do they follow APA formatting?
Can you identify any issues with the reference page?
If so, provide specific examples:
