Discuss strengths and weaknesses of the research article. In this comparison and analysis phase of the critique, consider how the research elements relate to one another, particularly in reference to the stated research design.

Qualitative Research critique

Discuss strengths and weaknesses of the research article. In this comparison and analysis phase of the critique, consider how the research elements relate to one another, particularly in reference to the stated research design. Here is a suggestion list of elements to consider. Reference your Research text also, as this is not an exhaustive list.
Is the research objective format at a comparable level to the stated design
Do the operational tools measure the concept
Do the data reflect the level of measurement necessary for the stated statistics used
Is the sampling method and plan style appropriate for the chosen research design
Has the author related the theoretical framework to concept variables, and outcomes
Is the problem heuristic to nursing, does the theoretical basis related to nursing concerns
Are limitations (both types) and biases addressed – can you identify possible concerns to generalizability
Validity and reliability of instruments / data : of outcomes due to uncontrolled threats
Does the author support the study rigor expected for the stated design
Are study variables – demographics, setting – controlled sufficiently for chosen research design
Specify examples
Justify your criticisms of these examples
Suggest research method alternatives
20