Discuss one 2019 Hospital National Patient Safety Goal within your paper/presentation and how it relates to your topic.
Quinsigamond Community College
NUR 202-FA Fall 2019
Evidence-Based Practice Paper and Presentation Guidelines
- Each student will develop an evidence based practice (EBP) paper and presentation emphasizing best practices on a medical-surgical topic related to course & clinical content. Topics must be approved by faculty. No duplication of topics is allowed within each clinical group.
- The paper will include the cover page, 2-3 pages for the body of the paper, and a reference list.
- For more info watch What is EBP (3 & ½ minute video) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2pJvBNszxIU&t=99s
- EBP explained https://www.amsn.org/sites/default/files/documents/practice-resources/evidence-based-practice/Evidence_Based_Practice_Module_I.pdf
- The paper must include a minimum of two professional nursing articles published within the past 5 years.
-
- Articles should be research or evidence based, preferably from nursing journals but may be from a related health field if appropriate for the topic
- Opinions, blogs, editorials, etc. are not research or evidence based
- QCC Library Research Process Guide: http://qcc.mass.libguides.com/researchprocess
- APA format
- Double spaced, one inch margins, with Times New Roman size 12 font
- Include a cover page, cite all sources quoted or paraphrased in the paper using APA format, and include a reference list with all cited sources listed in APA format.
-
- QCC APA Style Guide: http://qcc.mass.libguides.com/APA_Style
- Owl Purdue APA Guide: https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/560/18/
- Discuss one 2019 Hospital National Patient Safety Goal within your paper/presentation and how it relates to your topic. https://www.jointcommission.org/assets/1/6/2019_HAP_NPSGs_final2.pdf
https://www.jointcommission.org/hap_2017_npsgs/
- The presentation should be accompanied by a PowerPoint presentation, brochure, poster board, or other visual aid. Please be creative in the 10-15 minute presentation.
- The grading rubric specifies how points are allotted for the paper and presentation (after passing the course with at least 77 per the syllabus). Focus on the “Meets Expectations” column.
-
- Go to Clinical content folder – Assignments – Evidence-Based Practice Paper (Turnitin)
- Turnitin checks for plagiarism so make sure to cite all paraphrased and quoted material. All work not cited must be original to the student.
- Presentation date: See clinical rotation schedule/per clinical faculty.
Revised 8.7.19 STJ/MLM
Grading Rubric for Evidence-Based Practice Assignment
Performance Indicators | |||
Objective/Criteria | Unacceptable | Needs Improvement | Meets Expectations |
Spelling & Grammar | (0-1 point) Major spelling and grammar errors |
(3 points) Minor spelling and grammar errors |
(5 points) No spelling or grammar errors |
Submitted On Time | (0-1 point) Paper is submitted more than 24 hours after due date and time |
(3 points) Paper is submitted within 24 hours of due date and time |
(5 points) Paper is submitted by due date & time |
APA Style | (0-1 point) Major APA formatting errors with in text referencing or reference page |
(2-4 points) Minor APA formatting errors with in-text referencing or reference page |
(5 points) Paper and reference page strictly adheres to APA style formatting |
Quality of Evidence | (0 points) Evidence is based on non- evidence based sources or non-nursing/healthcare articles. |
(5-10 points) Evidence is based on less than 2 current nursing/healthcare articles or non-current (more than 5 years old). |
(15 points) Evidence is based on 2 current nursing/healthcare articles (within the past 5 years). |
Focus of Evidence | (0 points) Evidence does not provide implication for nursing practice. |
(5 points) Evidence provides some implication for nursing practice. |
(10 points) Evidence provides implication for nursing practice. |
NPSG Competency | (0 points)
Lacks evidence of integration of NPSG competency. |
(3-5 points)
Some evidence of integration of NPSG competency. |
(7 points) Integration of NPSG competencies discussed. |
Paper Length | (0-1 point) Body of paper is less than 2 pages and/or is not double-spaced with one-inch margins. |
(2 points) Body of paper is less than 2 pages, greater than 3 pages and/or is not double-spaced with one-inch margins. |
(3 points) Body of paper is 2-3 pages long and is double-spaced with one-inch margins. |
Content Organization | (0-2 points) Information is not clearly stated, supported, not easy to follow, and paper is difficult to understand. |
(5-10 points) Information is stated but not easy to follow. There is minimal support through nursing literature and application of concept into nursing |
(20 points) Information is clearly stated, supported, and easy to follow with integration of nursing literature found throughout the paper. Presents current standards and research based information on the topic. |
Total points for paper:_______
(max 70 points) |
Paper Comments:
|
||
Topic Choice | (0 point)
Does not define background and importance of topic |
(1-2 point)
Limited definition of background and importance of topic |
(2.5 points)
Defines background and importance of topic |
Organization | (0-0.5 point)
Information is not presented in a logical sequence |
(1-2 point)
Information is generally presented in a logical sequence |
(2.5 points)
Information is presented in a logical sequence |
Implication for Nursing | (0 point)
Implications for nursing not presented |
(1-2 point)
Implication for nursing is minimally presented and/or not specific to topic. |
(2.5 points)
Implications for nursing are presented and specific to topic. |
NPSG application | (0 point)
NPSG is not identified or discussed.
|
(1-2 point)
NPSG is discussed but does not align with chosen topic. |
(2.5 points)
NPSG aligns with chosen topic and is discussed. |
Speaking Skills Pronunciation | (0-0.5 point)
Speaker lacks eye contact, animation, and/or reads the presentation. |
(1-2 point)
Speaker is somewhat animated and makes eye contact during parts of the presentation. |
(2.5 points)
Speaker maintains good eye contact with the audience and is animated |
Delivery of Content | (0-0.5 point)
Delivery lacks poise and is not audible. Pronunciation is incorrect. |
(1-2 point)
Delivery is unclear and occasionally difficult to hear. Pronunciation is generally correct. |
(2.5 points)
Delivery is poised, clear and a Pronunciation is correct udible. |
Professional Attire | (0-0.5 point)
Dressed inappropriately. General attire not appropriate for audience (jeans, t-shirt, shorts). Lack of professional grooming, head to toe. |
(1-2 point)
Dressed in a casual, but not necessarily professional manner (revealing blouse, t-shirt, sneakers, etc.). Fairly neat. |
(2.5 points)
Dressed in a professional manner. Generally neat and well-groomed. |
Visual Aids | (0-0.5 point)
Visual aids poorly prepared, distracting, ineffective or not used |
(1-2 point)
Visual aids minimally prepared and/or somewhat distracting and ineffective |
(2.5 points)
Visual aids are well prepared, informative, effective, and not distracting |
Length | (0-0.5 point)
Length of presentation is more than 10 minutes over the time limit |
(1-2 point)
Length of presentation is less than 5 minutes or 5-10 minutes over the time limit |
(2.5 points)
Length of presentation is within the allotted time limit |
Accuracy | (0-0.5 point)
Information contains several inaccurate points and is not thorough |
(1-2 point)
Information contains few inaccurate points and/or is limited |
(2.5 points)
Information is communicated accurately and thoroughly |
Question Response | (0-0.5 point)
Speaker is unable to answer questions or requires correction of more than two answers by faculty for accuracy |
(1-2 point)
Speaker is limited in ability to answer questions and/or requires correction of 1-2 answers by faculty. |
(2.5 points)
Speaker is able to answer questions professionally and accurately |
Closing Statement | (0-0.5 point)
Lacks a conclusion to summarize the presentation |
(1-2 point)
Provides a limited conclusion to summarize the presentation. |
(2.5 points)
Provides an obvious conclusion to summarize the presentation. |
Total points for presentation: ________
(max 30 points) |
Presentation Comments: | ||
Paper and Presentation graded by: Date: __/__/___ |
Total EBP Project Points: __________ 80-86 (1 point), 87-93 (2 points), 94-100 (3 points)